Toegepast Etnobotanisch Onderzoek voor Duurzaam Gebruik van Non-Timber Forest Products (NTFPs) door Etnische Gemeenschappen in Bolivia

ir. Evert Thomas

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. Objectives
  3. Methodology
  4. Results


Introduction

The research for my PhD thesis is basically the continuation of a project titled ‘Applied Ethnobotany for the phytochemical-pharmacological evaluation of Bolivian plants: a multidisciplinary approach’ which was carried out by Ina Vandebroek from 1st of July 2000 until 30th of June 2002. My engineer thesis formed part of the first implementation phase of this project and included an inventory of medicinal plants and the use of remedies based on these plants by Bolivian healers to treat more than 20 different ailment categories. The medicinal application of plants is however but one aspect of the multi-purpose use of this genetically diverse resource. Non-Timber forest products (NTFPs), defined as all wild plant and animal products harvested from the forest or other natural and "man man-made" vegetation types of, except for industrial timber exploitation (Ros-Tonen et al., 1995), have a high value and especially so for traditional living societies. NTFPs fulfil a central role in the existence economy of traditional communities under the form of nutrition, shelter, clothing, fuel, construction material, medicines, animal food... (Principe, 1991). Ethnobotanists have, historically seen, always catalogued the ways people use plants. This inventory is still far from complete and that in a time in which the destruction of natural habitat with high bio-diversity and the inherent loss of traditional cultures, as well as their botanic and ecological knowledge, has reached a never earlier seen speed linked, (Prance, 1991; Lewington, 1993; Joyal, 1996; Etkin, 1998; Cox, 2000; Conservation international, 2001). Ecologists emphasise on the other hand with increasing insistence that biological conservation and the management of ecosystems require a human dimension to be successful (Mangel et al., 1996; Carpenter and Turner, 1998; Lubchenco, 1998; Kimmerer, 2000; Turner, 2000; Eghenter, 2000; Thomson, 2000; Colding and Folke, 2001). In this respect a number of authors (Posey, 1992; Hall and Bawa, 1993; Rodriguez-Navarro, 2000; Mauro and Haridson, 2000) point out the need to involve traditional communities that depend on a large variety of plant- and animal species, directly in the sustainable exploitation and conservation of tropical bio-diversity. Etkin (1998) and WWF (1998) go even still a step further: according to them local efforts have a larger chance on success if they take into account traditional ecological knowledge of, and experience with plant varieties.

Terug naar boven

Objectives

This research aims at a detailed study into the culture-nature-protection (conservation) area, in the department Cochabamba (Bolivië). The main objectives of the research are:

Terug naar boven

Methodology

The research takes place in two different ecosystems: on the one hand in Apillapampa, a campesino (peasant) community lain in the Bolivian Andes and on the other side five Trinitario and Yuracare communities of the National Park Isiboro Secure (tropical rain forest of Chapare, in the Bolivian lowland).
The research methodology consists of the following parts:

  1. Systematic ecological sampling in transects of 50 by 2 square meters. These have the advantage that they are fast to sample and produce comparable data (especially with the extend dataset of Alwyn Gentry (Phillips & Miller, 2003)) concerning alpha and Shannon diversity, taxonomic composition and the dominant species for the site, abundance, basal surface, etc. In Apillapampa all plant species growing to sizes over 0,1 m with the exception of grasses (Poaceae) were counted and measured while for the rainforest study sites all woody plants with a stem diameter(s) higher than 2.5 cm at 1 m 30 height will be measured, and for all other situations, except seedlings, the number of individuals will be counted.
  2. Field trips (or so called “walk in the woods”) with local plant specialists for identification of all local (therefore also including rare) plant species with a use value.
  3. Botanic identification of the collected plant species.
  4. Open ended and semi-structured interviews (as described in Bernard (1988), Martin (1995) and Alexiades (1996)) through information is obtained around the traditional use and perception of plants (including ecological data), as well as the traditional resource management (TRM) and the traditionally ecological knowledge (TEK) of natural vegetable wealth. These interviews contain beside questions concerning use and application also those specifically for degree of use, abundance (occurrence) in space (common, regular, rare, died out) and time (season-tied prevalence of especially herbs and annuals, in the past more abundant as compared to present?) and harvest methods. These interviews are performed on the one hand directly during the collection phase in the field (in the rainforest vegetation) and on the other according to the method described by Boom (1987) where plant specimen are collected in the field, brought back to the village and presented to the informants who then supply the requested information. The advantage of first method is that informants recognize the plant species more easily and with more certainty, while the advantage of the second method is that e.g. elder people who aren’t as mobile anymore can be included in the interviewing. Moreover, it is less time consuming.
  5. In both research areas some kind of feedback towards the local communities will be elaborated. As feedback is understood the publication of research results in a practically useful form for indigenous people and some cultivation or optimalization of NTFPs-producing plant species. The elaboration/concretisation of this feedback is to be completed in dialogue with the local actors (the NGOs and the communities).

Terug naar boven

Results

Apillapampa

Vegetable diversity by means of transect data
From of January 2003 up to April 2003 twenty-nine transects of fifty by two square meters were established and systematically sampled. All plant species growing higher than ten centimetres (excluded Poaceae)) (in this report further indicated with "plants > 0.1") were inventoried with annotation of their number of prevalence. The height of woody plant species was moreover measured. Plant species which fell outside this category (therefore Poaceae or plants growing smaller than ten centimetres), but are known, either by name, or because of a certain use and/or application were also incorporated in the inventory. At each of these transects environmental parameters were exhaustively noted down (degree of erosion, disturbance, slope, exposition, soil depth...) as well as the accessibility, expressed as travel time from the village of Apillapampa, to examine which factor has the largest influence on the vegetable bio-diversity (using Principal Components and Redundancy analysis - PCA resp. RDA). This period was therefore especially focussed on botanical and ecological aspects of the research, basically because most (and especially herbs) plants grow and flower during and after the rainy season. During the period from august to October 2003 seven extra transecten were sampled. As this period fell straight into the dry season, only woody plant species were taken into account, as these are the only species that can be recognised with certainty. Thus the analysis was carried out on the one hand on all plants > 0.1 and on the other side on a group of only woody plant species.

For each transect the diversity index of Shannon (H) which takes into account both number of species (richness) and number of individuals (evenness) within a given sampling surface, was calculated. This index was calculated for both plants > 0.1 and woody plant species. The diversity (both Shannon and alpha (α), i.e. number of different plant species) was evaluated in function of altitude above sea level and travel time by means of regression analysis. Travel time to the sampling sites is used as a parameter for the accessibility of that site. Given the mountainous nature of the research area this is a more realistic parameter than distance. Along rather horizontal roads for example larger distances can be covered as compared to climbing a mount path in given time lap. A number of the provisional most important results (with as altitude range: 2850-3750 m.a.s.l.) include:


Botanical
A total of 579 botanical samples was collected - sampled within transects and during different field trips - counting for about 450 different botanic plant species and 87 botanical families. Nearly all plant species - with exception of the specimen belonging to the Poaceae for which the identification process is still in full pace - are already identified up to species level using the available literature in Bolivia.

The most represented families are: Asteraceae (25%), Fabaceae (8%), Poaceae (7.5%), Solanaceae (5.3%), Lamiaceae (3,3%) and Scrophulariaceae (2.4%). These proportions are in conformity with earlier Bolivian floristic inventories in the ecosystem to which the research area belongs.

Of all collected plant species a specimen (with label) is deposited in the herbaria of both Cochabamba and La Paz. About twenty "problematic plant species" were sent to relevant specialists worldwide for identification. So far with certainty three new - i.e. species that were not described before - were collected (Philibertia nov. sp., Asclepiadaceae; Aeschynomene nov sp., Fabaceae; Dioscorea nov. sp., Dioscoreaceae). There is high probability (according the first responses of botanic specialists) that the inventory includes two more new species types of which extra material must be collected (one unknown species of the Malvaceae, and one Cardenanthus sp. (Iridaceae)).

Anthropological
Within the given time span twelve informants (four women, one child and seven men) were questioned by means of semi-structured ethnobotanical interview. These interviews were mainly carried out during the dry season, as at that moment most plants are absent at above-ground-level or in vegetative state which leaves less collection options. Systematically all collected plant species were shown to each informant (an average of 16 hours effectively interviewing per person). The questionnaire consists out of twenty questions with sub-chapters from which eight basic questions can be identified. Where appropriate these eight questions were discussed in more detail by means of the more specific questions the list. Based on the as such gathered ethnobotanical information the collected plants could be classified in a total of more than 20 use - or application categories (e.g. nutrition & beverage, fuel, construction, medicine, hygiene, spiritual value, etc.). More than 150 substantial uses/applications (e.g. make cheese, keeping ants away from crops, baskets) were registered.


Feedback
As feedback towards the community of Apillapampa was decided to compose a locally useful flora that compiles all collected plant species with their description and local uses and applications. A first step in this work was done by a biology student. Upgrading of the local plant diversity and its use may/will contribute to a bigger consciousness of the need to conserve it. A first realisation of feedback was given with a book on locally used medicinal plant species (Vandebroek, Thomas & AMETRAC, 2003) for which in the current research considerable information was collected. Another form of feedback with which has already been started is a reforestation project (+/- 5000 trees) in association with six villagers. We chose, after consultation of community members and on advise of the NGO Fepade, for on the one hand fruit species (Prunus spp. & Solanum betaceum Cav.) as an additional food source and on the other side multiple purpose trees (among others Acacia spp., Prosopis laevigata, Erythrina falcata) for fuel, fodder, timber, nutrition, etc. to plant. The seedlings have to be ready to be planted at the beginning of November 2004 (beginning of rainy season) when they will be distributed to all the families of Apillapampa.

Terug naar boven

Isiboro Secure


Mid-February 2004 was started with the research in the National Park Isiboro Secure. By means of the contacts with the NGO CINEP (Centro de Investigación y Educación Popular), which is operative in the aimed communities, the project was presented - with positive response (in hierarchical order): CPITCO (Coordinadora the Pueblos Indigenas del Tropico the Cochabamba), a central council that represents the majority of the communities of the tropics of Cochabamba; CONISUR, a council which is composed by two representatives of all communities lain in the national park Isiboro Secure; and the communities of which the representatives were enthusiastic and showed interest. Up till now about 150 plant species with a local use value were collected. These plant species have only partly been identified so floristic results are not included yet in this report.